Is Torture a Necessary Evil Essay Example for Free

Is Torture a Necessary Evil Essay14th September 2013Torture is a essential evil.After interpret this article and evaluating both sides of the argument, my opinion persists the same. I disagree that torture is necessary it is a barbaric breach of human rights. After looking at statistics, only 8% of Guantanamo detainees were Al Qaeda fighters, this is a shockingly low percentage in proportion to the 517 Guantanamo that were detained. British laws have deemed torture illegal and tho at least 6 detainees alleged that British forces were involved in the torture. Torturing can non go on the pros do not outweigh the cons of torture. In portentous circumstances, lives may be saved, but at what cost? Where does it end, as stated in the article, will family members become torture victims? As the initial suspect may not have value for their own life, they turn to his/her loved ones? If a suspect has been detained, regardless of what their crime may be, they still have the right to re main wordless. Any forced extraction of data goes against the fundamental human rights, and even if information is gained, what assurance do we have that it will be correct information? In the heat of the moment, it may seem that the information is true, to end the pain that the victim is in, yet it may all be fiction.These are clearly not risks worth taking, and in my opinion, anyone who is willing to submit a fellow human being to that amount of pain and discomfort, does not fill me with confidence in the accompaniment that they are in a position of power. In recent news, countries like the UK or the USA are undecided whether to involve themselves in the business of Syria they strike that involvement, in the sense of morals, is the right thing to do. Yet there is still a debate on whether torture should be legal, does one not neutralise the other(a)? It seems extremely hypocritical that on one hand, the armed forces have a sense of human rights in one way, yet on the other ha nd, claims that torture is necessary, which completely abolishes human rights in another way. In conclusion, regardless of the arguments in favour of torture, I still disagree that torture is a necessary evil it dehumanises victims, stripping them of their human rights, regardless of whether they may be Al Qaeda fighters, they still have the basic human right to remain silent during questioning, any way of obtaining information by forced means is morallywrong.